Thursday, September 15, 2011

Communication and Language

Language is a critical part of our cultural identity. We think about our world in the language that we know. Therefore, that language, by definition, must affect the way we view the world. For example, the Navajo do not have a word for war in their language. So, if we know that, it is not surprising to learn that conflict avoidance is an important characteristic of their culture. On the other hand, we use many words and phrases that relate to war and conflict. So, it is not surprising that we see a lot of conflict in our society.

Language is also an important social marker. We will talk more about this in the section on social stratification. However, a few points can be made here. Language, along with the clothes we wear, our hairstyles, the music we listen to, the car we drive, etc., are indicators of the social groups that we belong to. As we change groups – temporarily or permanently – we change those markers. Teens dress a certain way to demonstrate their differences from older generations. Their language operates in the same way. However, most young people learn that as they grow up and take on more responsibility – job and family – they must leave many of their teen markers behind them. When they go on a job interview they speak differently than they do with their friends and they dress differently (or they are unlikely to get that job).

In the same way, our dialects demonstrate our membership in certain cultural groups. All languages have many dialects. And, as your text explained, all dialects are correct in grammatical terms. I know that your English teachers have drilled into you that you must speak and write “correct” English. Linguistically, there is no such thing as correct English. There is only the dialect that our society has chosen to be the standard. And that standard changes. The standard dialect is connected to power and influence. The more powerful and influential group, the more their language, and other aspects of their culture are likely to be the standard for the society. We hold various groups up as “better” and hence their behavior and language are perceived of as “better.” Southern culture, particularly Appalachian culture has been viewed as less than by large portions of our society. Therefore, the dialects spoken there have been perceived of as less than. And, many judge people who speak those dialects as less than. One student mentioned that Ebonics was "acceptable."  I think we need to make it clear that what is "correct" is not always "acceptable."  Ebonics is not considered acceptable in the larger society, but it is correct.  Even though the various dialects in our country are grammatically correct, they are not all "acceptable."

A study was conducted using different dialects when calling to inquire about an apartment. The person renting the apartment judged the person on the other end of the call by the way they talked. This is ethnocentrism. That doesn’t mean that we should not learn Standard English. We must if we are to be successful in our society. However, it is important for us to understand, and our teachers to teach, that Standard English is important in many contexts, but does not necessarily need to replace one’s own dialect. I think we do a disservice to minority groups by portraying their dialects as “incorrect.” Basically, by doing that we are telling them that their culture is “incorrect.” Asking people to change their language is asking them to change their identity. Yet, altering our language and other social markers in specific contexts, is important for success in our culture.  These issues of language and our understanding of language have important implications for policy, particularly in how we teach our young people.

I want you to think back to the discussion about ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. Is one of these ways of speaking – Navajo or English speaking American – better than the other? I think the more important question is, “Why do these languages have such different vocabularies?” Are they adaptations to a particular environment – physical, political, social?

The danger of examining one’s own culture is that our initial tendency is to be critical of what we see. While we may be confrontational and argumentative, there are reasons for that. The important question is what are those reasons? To truly understand a culture – anothers or our own – these are the questions we need to ask ourselves. We can reserve judgment for later. Understanding must come first.

We will continue to discuss various aspects of culture that will force you to look at your own culture. One of my goals for this class is for the students to examine other cultures, as well as their own, and begin to understand why cultural diversity exists. Try to refrain from judgment and focus more on why those differences exist, what function do they serve for that particular society, and are those differences adaptive.

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Foraging Societies - Stephanie Reynolds

Forgaging societies have played a large part in the developement of later societies seen today. Our ancestors survivied on foraging or hunting for food, and had to learn new survival skills in order to adapt to the changing environment. Anthropologists can gain a wealth of information from foraging societies since they learn when "true humans" evolved and what the world was like back then. Not only did these socieities give anthropologists a good timeline of evolution, but they were also widespread across the continents. Because of this, it makes it much easier for anthropologists to compare various socieities, found both in North America and Africa, and find the similarities between them. Societies who remained as foragers, even to this day, need to be studied as well to find out why they did not evolve into more complex social forms. To truly understand technology, no matter how advanced it's become, anthropologists must also understand where it all began. It's similar to the saying "in order to understand the future, we must not forget to understand our past and where we came from [foraging societies.]

Anthropologists can learn so much from these groups, especially what factors led to Revolution and innovation. Also, we learn about evolution of a species, and how it affected the surrounding environment, or how the environment affected evolution. When the tools and artifacts associated with foraging were found centuries later, anthropologists discovered even more about an individual foraging society. For example, with the discovery of a spear, an anthropologist learns: (1) the society relied on hunting for survival, (2) what kinds of materials were needed to make the spear and where they were found, and (3) what types of animals could be huntied during that time. By compiling all of this information together across all of the continents, except Antartica, anthropologists get a better idea if how our original foraging society compares to those all over the world.

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Making a Living

For this week (Sept. 12-17)  read Chapter 5 -  Making a Living - and the following articles:
Understanding Eskimo Science
The Inuit Paradox
Why Can't People Feed Themselves

Discussion Assignment:
Why do anthropologists study foraging societies? What can we learn from these groups?
Respond to at least two of your classmates.

This assignment should be completed by midnight, September 17.

Monday, September 12, 2011

Comments

If you are having problems commenting on other student's post, but can publish a new post, create a new post in which you identify and address two other student's post.  I am investigating this issue.  However, it seems to be affecting only a small number of students and we can get around it this way in the meantime.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Communication, Dawn D

Drawing on this module's readings discuss the ways in which language shapes a people's concept of reality. Does the language that we use affect the way we see the world, or does the way we see the world affect the language that we use?

Humans communicate with one another using a dazzling array of languages, each differing from the next in innumerable ways.

We are symbol makers because we can conceptualize. A symbol is an empty sound until we associate a meaning with that sound, until we fill the symbol with an idea, a notion, a concept. We look at nature and we name things, categorize items, classify types, and define the properties of objects. The symbols become numinous, take on lives of themselves, then spread like viruses from person to person, from generation to generation, from age to age.

Without symbols, humans would never have left the caves, would never have learned to speak, to write, to create abstract mathematical formulae for the creation of engineering and architecture; without symbols, humans would never have created music or art or poetry, or publish progressive magazines.

But words also have the power to destroy, to hurt, to spread hatred because preconceived notions are passed from person to person, from generation to generation, from age to age. What you can imagine about a place, an object, or a person depends upon the knowledge you were given by your parents, by your prophets, by your teachers, and your peers.

Language shapes reality because we create symbols that represent objects and abstract concepts. In our minds the symbol becomes the thing. Language users manipulate those symbols in order to shape reality to fit their own agendas. These manipulators of language know our needs, our values, and our desires. These manipulators understand how we emotionally react to symbols, and most importantly understand that most of their audience either can't decipher the argument or they are too complacent to bother.

People who speak different languages do indeed think differently and that even flukes of grammar can profoundly affect how we see the world. Language is a uniquely human gift, central to our experience of being human

Chapter 4 Language

I think that people's concept of reality is shaped by language. People in their own cultures tend to have similar views on topics, which is what makes a culture. Some people thought that Ebonics was less important to teach than Standard English. They stressed that it was inferior and they related Ebonics to lower class, unintelligible social groups. Soon most people started seeing Ebonics in the same light.
I think that the way we see the world affects the way we see certain languages. I see Paris, France as this beautiful, romantic place. So I associate speaking and listening to French as beautiful and a romantic language. I see the Country accent in America homey, comforting, and relaxed. I like this accent opposed to the New York accent. I think that is sounds obnoxious and rude. People in that culture may not be rude and obnoxious but that's how I perceive them because of the way I see their accent.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Discussion 4-Sara Bugler

Language is used to shape the world we know as soon as we are born. We use words to describe the world around us. Our history may change the meaning of a word as time goes by. At times we also inherit language from other cultures. With everything that goes on from war, to disasters, hunger, and even the evolution of facebook we adapt words to fit into our understanding. For instance the word Jihad is meant to be a holy or moral struggle that stresses the non-militant sense of the word, while Western cultures now assimilate it with holy war and terrorism.