Thursday, September 8, 2011

Language & Communication, Sam Stangl

In the 3 articles that we read, I found that language is a barrier between cultures, but it is not solid: the barrier can be broken and passed with the right use of words, phrases, and body language, even. I especially loved the article about Hamlet, and how the man learned about more than just what the story means when considering it from the elders' perspective, but also learned more about the metaphors connecting cultures that people can compare to universally. He used their language and their word use to explain Hamlet as a story that they would like, one that they could understand and relate to. Also, I like the anonymous quote from the third article that reads, "it is not the case that a man who is silent says nothing." This, to me, sums up a large amount of information into one short sentence, and it is completely true. A man who is silent is a man with much more on his mind, usually, and he may be saying something without ever opening his mouth. It is possible, and it happens with people around the world.

The textbook says a lot about communication and language. It tells how there are dialects within a culture, and they do not sound like the formal and "correct" way that the language is spoken, but they are understandable, and they logically represent the idea that a person want's to convey. The example was the use of ebonics in English language: ebonics is considered by some more than others to be another correct form of English that should be taken as seriously and read as fluently as formal English.

I think that a culture's vocabulary shapes their concepts of reality in a drastic way. For example, the African people in the first article about Hamlet did not believe in a significant afterlife, and thus did not have a word for Heaven, ghost, or those kinds of things. They did not understand the concept of a person's soul or spirit roaming the earth to seek out unfufilled duties in order to rest in peace. And for them, there was just no need to. Thus, the language we use affects the way we see the world, because it determines what we think exists, and how we think things work. However, what we see in the world also determines the vocabulary we need, as we are likely to be able to come up with a word for something even if there is no literal term for such a thing. In English, there is almost no way to come up short of a word, especially because you can piece words together to create your own word with its own meaning, but it is understandable because of the similarity to other words that are used to create this word.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Module 4 Communication - Stephanie Reynolds

In the textbook, language is not completely considered a result of genetics, but instead a social factor. Children learn the language they were the most exposed to, and are not predisposed to learn any one language. Language itself though can somewhat shape an individual's concept of reality since language is a large part of communicating with others. For example, for a tourist trying to speak with a native using the native language, the tourist may see some cultural language factors differently. Also, the way in which language is used can shape a person's concept of reality. For those who use the "proper" form of languagem they may have better job opportunities and a higher chance of becoming successful. With this added success comes a more positive view of reality and maybe a happier lifestyle for the individual. People who do not use the approved language form may not always receive these benefits, and as a result, not have such a positive outlook of reality.
  After reading the different articles and the textbook chapter, I really think the way we see the world affects the language that we use. An individual who sees the world in a negative way may not consider communicating with others in the native language really important. Also, individuals who view the world positively may be more inclined to use language more often and in the more accepted form.

Communication and Language

For this week, read Chapter 4 in your text -  Communication.
Also, read the following articles:
Shakespeare in the Bush
Conflict and Confluence in Advertising Meetings
To Give Up on Words:  Silence in Western Apache Culture (this is difficult to read because of the format of the website, but it is a very interesting article if you can get past the weird formatting)


Discussion Assignment:
Drawing on this week's readings, discuss the ways in which language shapes a people's concept of reality. Does the language that we use affect the way we see the world, or does the way we see the world affect the language that we use?

This assignment should be completed by midnight Saturday, September 10.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Discussion 3

The "ideal" relationship between anthropologists and the key informants is when the informants provide regular information to the anthropologist to help them blend in among the population.
There are a few problems with obtaining these relationships though. An anthropologist could say or do something that will offend the informants without knowing or they may get an informant that is all about the money and give them wrong information on what the culture is all about. You have to be able to know what you are being told is the real deal. Friendship is very important for an anthropologist to have with the informants. It makes it easier to get information from the informant and makes it easier for the populous to accept you into their culture and allow you to participate in their rituals.However it could make it to where the informant will tell the anthropologist what he wants to hear to either make the anthropologist happy or for the anthropologist give him something nice.

Saturday, September 3, 2011

Discussion - Sam Pilson

Genuine interest is essential when you are trying to study people. More than anything else, people want to talk about themselves, however they need someone to listen. Trust is equally important, for people are more apt to open up to someone they trust.

It may be a risk to become too involved, however. Becoming part of cultural drama may hinder the information gathering process. If you become emotionally attached, you may be less likely to portray your informants objectively.

To minimize these risks, an anthropologist needs to have a professional mindset. Assimilating with the culture for scientific purposes is good, but emotional attachment may not be. One could go so far as to say being a little ethnocentric may keep an anthropologist in an academic state of mind.

Chapter 3, Dawn Depouli

An "ideal" relationship between an anthropologist and the key informants would be a relationship that is based on respect, and friendship should be the last. Considering that anthropologist do research on there key informants, Respect comes with any business deal that you perform. When you show respect typically it can only benefit you in the long run. Friendship is one that should not be part of the ideal relationship, they always say that you should never mix friendship with business and I believe in the fully. When you involve friendship often times that friend may expect more from you than you should be willing to give. Just because you are a friend doesn’t mean you should have to compromise your work. This could ultimately get in the way of research and result in you not getting the information you may need. It can also cause you to be biased and not reflect on the true results. When you involve friendship and business you are no longer looked at as an authority figure and not taken serious as you should be. Professionalism should be the number one key at all times.

Chapter 3 - Sierra Armstrong

The ideal relationship between an anthropologist and an informant would be the informant teaching the basics of the culture being studied to the anthropologist. I think the basics should be the language and the basic roles of the different people. I think that would help the anthropologist communicate with the other people in the culture so that the anthropologist can come up with their own ideas and observations of that culture. Also it allows the anthropologist to get information from more than one person. A problem with this is that the anthropologist and the informant might get along very well. The anthropologist might continually go back to the informant instead of the other people to understand why someone said this instead of asking that person. Like when Greg Simon was working in Bukittingi the people were mean and cold towards him. So if Simon had an informant that he was friends with he might have gone to the informant to ask why he said that or acted that way. Instead of the informant trying to explain why his culture acts that way he may and try to comfort Simon and tell him not to worry about that guy. Also if an informant and the anthropologist were not friends the informant could tell the anthroplogist only what he wanted him to know about his culture. Then that culture would not be accurately portrayed. Friendships between informants and anthroplogist will cause problems. If the two become very good friends the anthropologist may keep certain details or important about that culture out of their writings to protect that culure and his friend. Then that goes againist their code of ethics because an anthropologist is supposed to report his information to the general public, but the anthropologist is also not supposed to do anything that can hurt the people. That is a controversy all in itself. I think to try and help this the anthropologist should do as much research on that culture that he can find so that he will not be totally in culture shock. This will allow him to maybe communicate with more people in the culture instead of just one person. I think no matter what there are still going to be problems because all cultures are different. Even though this way works for this culture and doesn't bother them it may bother another culture.