Saturday, September 3, 2011
Chapter 3- Abbey Dahl (forgot the title the first time)
An "ideal" relationship between an anthropologist and the key informants would be a relationship that based on respect. An anthropologist, whether doing fieldwork in another country or within their own culture, needs to respect the people they are doing research on. Also vise versa. The people who are being researched must have respect for the anthropologist because the studier is trying to find out more about their interesting culture. If one was studying their own culture/society it could be problematic because they have to potential in their research to be bias/ethnocentric. If one was studying an outside culture this relationship could be difficult because the people might be skeptical about the anthropologist. Although it would be pleasant to create friendships while in fieldwork, I feel as if it would complicate the objectiveness of the research. Getting too close to the informants might create a bias with the research so it could not be as reliable. An anthropologist must have a kind of trustful relationship with the society at hand because they want valuable and truthful information to write about. The anthropologist just cannot cross any boundaries that might affect how the society views him. An anthropologist would be able to minimize these issues by making sure their view is still objective because as an outsider they want their information to sound liable.
An "ideal" relationship between an anthropologist and the key informants would be a relationship that based on respect. An anthropologist, whether doing fieldwork in another country or within their own culture, needs to respect the people they are doing research on. Also vise versa. The people who are being researched must have respect for the anthropologist because the studier is trying to find out more about their interesting culture. If one was studying their own culture/society it could be problematic because they have to potential in their research to be bias/ethnocentric. If one was studying an outside culture this relationship could be difficult because the people might be skeptical about the anthropologist. Although it would be pleasant to create friendships while in fieldwork, I feel as if it would complicate the objectiveness of the research. Getting too close to the informants might create a bias with the research so it could not be as reliable. An anthropologist must have a kind of trustful relationship with the society at hand because they want valuable and truthful information to write about. The anthropologist just cannot cross any boundaries that might affect how the society views him. An anthropologist would be able to minimize these issues by making sure their view is still objective because as an outsider they want their information to sound liable.
Chapter 3 - Becca Libby
I feel like the relationship between an anthropologist and their key informants depend completely on the culture and people they are studying. The book talks about how more and more anthropologists are studying their own societies rather that exotic peoples across the world. So for someone working in/with their own society, I feel it would be better to use informants that you do not know rather than people in your own town. Seems to me making friends is not a good strategy for getting information in your own society. I know if I were an anthropologist wanting to do a survey about (for example) what peoples' main use of their computers is, I wouldn't want to interview my friends or family. I would want to talk to people and learn from people I have never met, it makes the whole thing more subjective. Working with friends in your own culture makes complicates things much more that making friends in a different culture. If I go across the world to study a society I know nothing about, it will be hard for me to talk to anyone at first. This is why in other societies it is much more important to make/have friends. In the article about the ice hunters the anthropologist is good friends with the man he is traveling with, and it makes it much easier for him to feel comfortable being in a setting he is not accustomed to. One thing that caught my attention was when he said "We have traveled together many times since 1996...so there is no need for words." I think this really says a lot about the relationship between the two men. I believe that the fact that they were so close, made his work much easier and more accurate. Friendships in cultures less like your own are obviously harder to create. It may take a longer for another society to get used to you, than for you to get used to them. Trust plays a huge role in this, you have to know your boundaries until you become more integrated into a society. To avoid issues with mistrust and misunderstanding, an anthropologist has to slowly become integrated, rather than jumping right in to asking questions and trying to get information that could be offensive or misunderstood by that culture. This may be why many anthropologists now work with their own cultures, no doubt these problems arise less frequently.
Thursday, September 1, 2011
Ch.3 & Key Informants, Sam Stangl
An ideal relationship between an anthropologist and his or her key informants would be one where both parties understand each other and can communicate on a better level than the anthropologist can with others in the group or community. The scientist must have a real trust for the party (or parties) that informs him of all key relationships within their tribe, and the informant must have an equally legitimate trust for the anthropologist studying him and his tribe in order to tell him secrets like names of dead loved ones, or to tell him truths about who plays what role and how they life their lives. Even for the anthropologist to trust a translator would take a great deal of trust, in my opinion.
There could be a lot of problems that arise from having an informant, one of them being a hard time keeping confidentiality in check. Again, trust is a thick boundary that one must cross by giving or recieving information that others may wish not to be "gossiped" about, if you will. In some cases, the people will gang up on the anthropologist and waste his time by only giving him bogus information as some sort of joke, such as in one of the stories we read. Another problem is that one could end up, whether intentionally or not, favoriting the informants, treating them better, and the others in the community could see that and perhaps you would cause a flurry of jealousy among a culture that frowns upon those kinds of feelings.
I don't think there is a way for anthropologists to rid the problems they have with informants, but they can deal with them and "minimize" them by just being very cautious with who and what they trust, and what other evidence they can gather to back everything up scientifically. Thus, they at least rid the problem of trust vs. distrust.
There could be a lot of problems that arise from having an informant, one of them being a hard time keeping confidentiality in check. Again, trust is a thick boundary that one must cross by giving or recieving information that others may wish not to be "gossiped" about, if you will. In some cases, the people will gang up on the anthropologist and waste his time by only giving him bogus information as some sort of joke, such as in one of the stories we read. Another problem is that one could end up, whether intentionally or not, favoriting the informants, treating them better, and the others in the community could see that and perhaps you would cause a flurry of jealousy among a culture that frowns upon those kinds of feelings.
I don't think there is a way for anthropologists to rid the problems they have with informants, but they can deal with them and "minimize" them by just being very cautious with who and what they trust, and what other evidence they can gather to back everything up scientifically. Thus, they at least rid the problem of trust vs. distrust.
Ideal
Discussion Assignment:
Discuss what would be an "ideal" relationship between the anthropologist and the key informants? What kinds of problems might an anthropologist encounter with these relationships? Would friendships with informants affect the research? If so, how? How could an anthropologist avoid or minimize those problems?
Discuss what would be an "ideal" relationship between the anthropologist and the key informants? What kinds of problems might an anthropologist encounter with these relationships? Would friendships with informants affect the research? If so, how? How could an anthropologist avoid or minimize those problems?
An ideal relationship with an anthropologist and his/ her key informants would be the way that they survey them. The problems that they might face would be, not getting the right information or not enough information about them. I think that if they had a friendship with the informant it would make it a lot easier on them because they already would know about the person and their research would be a lot more accurately written down.
Chapter 3: Sara Bugler
The ideal relationship between an anthropologist and their and key informants should be a shared consensus of each other. Key informants may become more aware of their actions or even un-trusting of the interest that the anthropologist has. I think that engaging in friendship might disrupt the observations of an anthropologist. In friendship one is less subjective, and tends to let small things go by the wayside. For an anthropologist part of their observations need to be judging the culture and their values. An anthropologist must be appropriate with the people, be courteous of any customs of values the culture has, and be diligent in the study.
Chapter 3 Assignment - Stephanie Reynolds
An "ideal" relationship between the anthropologist and the key informants should not be as we would expect to see in the Western culture. I think more of a mutual understanding between the two parties is more important instead. Friendship, in my opinion, is when two people or groups can give and take from one another without one party becoming judgmental over the other one. In this case, the anthropologist may end up becoming a sort of "judge" of the key informants and make decisions about their culture based on limited research. The mutual understanding between the anthropologist and the key informants ensures that the peoples' rights and are being protected and not put at risk. The anthropologist would not be viewed as a "spy" or invader and is more likely to be trusted by the members of the society.
An anthropologist faces the problem of not being accepted or could end up not becoming integrated within the new culture enough. With Greg Simon, his feelings and experiences in Indonesia made him feel isolated and very frustrated, which could result in a lack of progress concerning his research. Simon had a negative experience with the Indonesian culture, which could be a problem with any anthropologist. Also, another problem which could arise with an over-friendly relationship between the anthropologist and key informants include the chance of the anthropologist choosing the opinions of a select few within a culture. This will exlude the valuable opinions and chance of more concrete research of the wider public of the culture. This more limited view would skew the results of research within the culture, causing problems and inaccuracy in the research later on. Friendships could really affect an anthropologist's research, so it may be better if there was more of a mutual understanding, built on trust and just for the sake of research, instead a Western culture type friendship.
The anthropologist will run into problems with key informants; it is inevitable. Although it is not always the anthropologist's fault, the anthropologist needs to find ways to avoid those problems as much as possible. Sometimes the key informant is not always being cooperative, he/she wants to push an individual opinion further, or isn't completely truthful with the anthropologist for whatever reason. To minimize these types of problems, the anthropologist must assure the key informant(s)' opinions are important, but should rely on more concrete evidence concerning the entire culture instead. The anthropologist could always work with other researchers in the field, if he/she feels the informants weren't being truthful, to collaborate and cross-reference whatever research was gained. This will allow different key informants to be utilized, as well as act as a sort of double check system for the anthropologist to stay on track.
An anthropologist faces the problem of not being accepted or could end up not becoming integrated within the new culture enough. With Greg Simon, his feelings and experiences in Indonesia made him feel isolated and very frustrated, which could result in a lack of progress concerning his research. Simon had a negative experience with the Indonesian culture, which could be a problem with any anthropologist. Also, another problem which could arise with an over-friendly relationship between the anthropologist and key informants include the chance of the anthropologist choosing the opinions of a select few within a culture. This will exlude the valuable opinions and chance of more concrete research of the wider public of the culture. This more limited view would skew the results of research within the culture, causing problems and inaccuracy in the research later on. Friendships could really affect an anthropologist's research, so it may be better if there was more of a mutual understanding, built on trust and just for the sake of research, instead a Western culture type friendship.
The anthropologist will run into problems with key informants; it is inevitable. Although it is not always the anthropologist's fault, the anthropologist needs to find ways to avoid those problems as much as possible. Sometimes the key informant is not always being cooperative, he/she wants to push an individual opinion further, or isn't completely truthful with the anthropologist for whatever reason. To minimize these types of problems, the anthropologist must assure the key informant(s)' opinions are important, but should rely on more concrete evidence concerning the entire culture instead. The anthropologist could always work with other researchers in the field, if he/she feels the informants weren't being truthful, to collaborate and cross-reference whatever research was gained. This will allow different key informants to be utilized, as well as act as a sort of double check system for the anthropologist to stay on track.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)